Rubric: Systematic Review Evidence Table Systematic Review Evidence Table Criteria Ratings Pts

Rubric: Systematic Review Evidence Table

Systematic Review Evidence Table

Criteria

Ratings

Pts

Final listing of included studies

After literature searching, screening titles and abstracts, selecting and reading full text articles, the team identifies and includes in the evidence table all studies that meets inclusion criteria and are a part of the final systematic review analysis – all peer reviewed studies are focused on answering PICOSS question and meets inclusion criteria are included on the evidence table.

15 pts

ACOTE B.6.1

Design and implement a systematic review (including analysis and synthesis of data) that is based on current research priorities and advances knowledge translation, professional practice, service delivery, or professional issues.

threshold: 3.0 pts

5 pts

Author – Year doi

Listing of the last names of the authors followed by the year of publication. Includes the doi after the author names is included for all studies on the table and will be included in the review process.

5 pts

Level of Evidence / Study Design / Study Participants / Inclusion Criteria

Level of Evidence / Study Design / Study Participants / Inclusion Criteria Listing the level of evidence for the study. Listing the type of study design. Listing of the number of study participants. Include percent male and female and the mean age or age range,if included. If the study has more than one group, list the number in each group. Listing of the inclusion criteria

10 pts

Intervention and Control Groups

Listing of only the interventions and control groups relevant to answering the focused PICOSS question.

5 pts

Outcome Measures

Listing of the name of the measure(s) used in the study that directly relate to the focused PICOSS question.

5 pts

Results

Listing of only the results of the study that are appropriate to answering the focused PICOSS question.
Indication of whether the results are statistically significant is included.

5 pts

Total Points: 50