4 – read paper and provide feedback/review

You read the following paper and write the review in attached review format.    Use “X” in review format. Overall comments and changes that MUST be made before publication: 

Please write the detailed comments on paper and review here (say in 5 – 10 bullet points)

Suggestions which would improve the quality of the paper but are NOT essential   for publication:

Please write the suggestions to improve the paper here (say in 3 or 4 bullet points)