Ethical Dilemma Rubric will be used to evaluate your responses to the ethics assignments.
Up to 12 points
Acceptable 13 to 17 points
18 to 20 points
Has no idea or only a vague idea of the ethical dilemma(s).
Identifies the ethical dilemma or dilemmas.
Describes the dilemma(s) in detail, including most or all pertinent facts. Clarifies why it is an ethical dilemma.
Is unsure about who the stakeholders are or does not identify any stakeholders.
Accurately identifies at least one important stakeholder who would be affected by the decision.
Accurately identifies several important stakeholders who would be affected by the decision and describes how they would be affected.
and Consequences and impact on stakeholders
Does not identify alternatives and consequences or suggests alternatives that are not reasonable.
Identifies at least one reasonable alternative and its possible consequences.
Identifies at least two reasonable alternatives and their possible consequences.
Analysis of ethical schools of thought
Has no idea or only a vague idea of the ethical schools of thought
Has some idea of the ethical schools of thought
Explains thoroughly the ethical schools of thought and its application to the scenario.
Provides a rationale for the decision
Does not recommend a decision or recommends a decision that does not reflect careful thought.
Provides no rationale or an inadequate rationale for the decision.
Recommends a decision that demonstrates some careful thought. Provides an adequate rationale for the decision.
Recommends a well thought
out, coherent, logical decision. Provides a strong rationale for the decision.
Total Points Overall Evaluation